Custom Cake FAQs

When should I book?

The earlier the better! I'm a one-woman show, so spots fill up fast, especially in the wedding frenzy months (May-June and Sept-Oct). If you need a last minute cake, I’ve got a great selection in the Ready to Order Online Shop

Do you make vegan/gluten free/allergen friendly desserts?

I offer gluten free cakes and desserts for those with gluten sensitivities. I do not offer vegan or dairy free desserts.

Allergens: While I take precautions, my kitchen is not a dedicated allergen-free facility. Equipment may come into contact with nuts, gluten, and other common allergens. If you or your guests have severe allergies, I recommend contacting a bakery with a dedicated allergen-free facility to ensure everyone can safely enjoy a treat.

How do I secure booking?

Once we've fine-tuned all the details, you can book it with a full payment or a 50% deposit. Dates are not reserved until an order and payment are in place.

What is your pricing structure?

All cakes start $7.50. The base pricing for our cakes covers the cake itself and that luscious buttercream. If you're craving extra fillings or flavors, there's a little extra love added there. And for those show-stopping designs with intricate details, toppers, and all the beautiful bells and whistles, we'll work out a design fee based on the complexity.

Can I request a custom design or flavor not listed?

Absolutely! Let's chat about your ideas.

Flavors: If I have a trusted recipe, you're in luck! New flavor territory? I've got plenty of delicious options on the menu to choose from.

Designs: I'm happy to customize within my style and abilities. If it's outside my expertise, I'll be upfront and we can find a fabulous alternative. Need something totally different? I can happily recommend another talented baker.

Do you offer tastings or consultations?

Takes the Cake offers a periodic cake and dessert tasting boxes. Check out the upcoming dates here.

Do you deliver custom cakes?

Delivery is available with order minimums of $500. Local delivery is $45 within Salem and Roanoke City. Delivery is required for cakes with 3 tiers or more.

How does pick up work?

Takes the Cake is a private microbakery, so pickups are scheduled by appointment. You'll receive the address once your order is paid.

Need a contactless option? I offer convenient porch-style pickups with my trusty patio cooler.

How do I store the cake before the event?

Your cake will be nice and chilled for pickup. That chill not only keeps the buttercream looking sharp but also ensures a sturdy journey home. When you arrive, pop that beauty into the fridge until 2 hours before the serving extravaganza begins.

Cakes are like the life of the party—they're at their best when enjoyed at room temperature. Just a friendly reminder: if you've got cheesecakes or any cakes with curd or fruit fillings, keep them cool when they're not on display.

How do I cut a tall cake? I’m scared!

Don’t be intimidated! I'll give you a step-by-step guide when you swing by for pickup, complete with a handy serving chart. But if you're feeling the need for cake-cutting wisdom right this moment, check out this video: Cake Cutting 101